In the brief window between Terry McPhillips’s resignation and the re-appointment of Simon Grayson, I allowed my mind to run wild with various sensational and left-field options to occupy the then-vacant Blackpool FC manager’s post. A return for one-time messiah Ian Holloway, I wondered. Charlie Adam as player-manager, I speculated. I even flirted with the idea of Roy Keane kickstarting his managerial career at Bloomfield Road before concluding that I would like to have seen Newport County boss Mike Flynn given the job.
Having performed admirably at the Welsh club under draconian financial restrictions a move to Blackpool would have represented a step up in class for Flynn and given that he had two spells at Bloomfield Road as a player, I think it is unlikely he would have turned down any would-be offer.
Flynn’s appointment would have probably been more exciting than Grayson’s as there is always a sense that a manager with a thus far unblemished record could be the next big thing; but by the same token, there was always the possibility the jump in level and expectation could prove too much for Flynn.
New owner Simon Sadler evidently thought as much if Flynn did ever come into the reckoning as what we have ended up with is a safe pair of hands, not a bright young coach.
Grayson once fitted such a description, ironically when he was last at Blackpool and left for his boyhood club Leeds United in December 2008. But the intervening years, though not without their successes, have not been kind to his reputation.
Though his credentials at League One level are sterling, he has stewarded us, Leeds, Huddersfield Town and (holds nose) Preston North End out of the division, he is widely regarded to have been found out at Championship level, even the most talented of his teams (Leeds) plateauing outside of the play-offs.
And while a failure to turn Championship teams into legitimate promotion contenders by no means disqualifies him for the Blackpool job, his two most recent managerial outings do raise further question marks against his name.
First, there is his time at Sunderland, where he won just one league game and was sacked after four months. But more worrying from a Blackpool perspective, is his record in his last job, in charge of Bradford City.
Grayson’s remit on arrival at Valley Parade was to guide the Bantams to promotion, with the Yorkshire side just outside the play-offs. But City faltered under his stewardship winning only three games on the way to finishing eleventh, which puts a blot against his record as the quintessential League One manager and raises doubts about his abilities to succeed on his return to Bloomfield Road that would not otherwise have been there.
Personally, I’m prepared to give him a pass on both of his last two jobs. He’s not the first decent manager to fail at Sunderland and I imagine arriving to take up the reigns there must have been akin to turning up to clean a derelict mansion armed with nothing more than a toothbrush and a small cup of water. The Bradford episode is more surprising as it’s a job I’d have expected him to do better in given his record, especially given that he won promotion with Huddersfield in 2012 after arriving in February, but again, I’m willing to let that slide.
His three best spells as a manager came with us, Leeds and at Preston and in each of these jobs he was afforded pre-seasons and the opportunity to build his own team.
Though (thankfully) he never looked like finishing in the play-offs with Preston, he did well enough at Deepdale to convince a club like Sunderland to appoint him and that was only two years ago and despite his two failures since I think there is still enough in his body of work to suggest his return won’t be a car crash.
His biggest strength has always been his ability to bring in quality players and this is a commodity Blackpool, after several years operating under austerity measures, are in short supply of.
In his first spell at Bloomfield Road, Grayson brought in the majority of the players involved in the club’s promotion to the Premier League in 2010, with seven of the players who represented the Seasiders in the play-off final in 2010 being his signings. At Leeds, he brought in some genuine fan’s favourites in Ross McCormack and Max Gradel, not to mention Kasper Schmeichel. And at Preston, he signed the likes of Aiden McGeady, Greg Cunningham, and Jordan Hugill, all of whom were sold on for a profit. He also seems to have something of a knack for identifying future England goalkeepers, taking Jordan Pickford on loan at Preston in a similar fashion to the way he once took a young Joe Hart on loan at Blackpool.
Tactically, there was never anything too sophisticated going on during Grayson’s time at Blackpool, it tended to be a 4-4-2 with players in their correct positions. Giving Wes Hoolahan license to roam in search of the ball was about as complicated as it got.
This is perhaps why Ian Holloway with his adventurous 4-3-3 was able to get players Grayson had brought in (I’m thinking Ian Evatt, Alex Baptiste and David Vaughan in particular) to reach levels many would have previously thought beyond them. And it is perhaps Grayson’s somewhat rudimentary tactical repertoire that has seen him hit a ceiling in the Championship throughout his career.
But Blackpool are not a Championship side and it is clear from this appointment that the question mark over Grayson’s record in the second tier is very much a bridge that can be crossed at a later date in the mind of the new owner.